If there’s one thing you’ve got to admit about me, it’s that I’m pretty, pretty good at making friends on the internet. No one can say otherwise. And another thing is that I consider myself a towering intellect on bullshit movies you can find on Tubi. So as I’ve gone through the forgotten films of the 1970s—and subsequently posting a brief review of them on that Mark Zuckerberg app—I came across I Walk the Line. NOT that damn Joaquin Phoenix movie. I Walk the Line. A big critical distinction, even though they get their titles from the same Johnny Cash song.
I Walk the Line was released in 1970 and is directed by legendary filmmaker John Frankenheimer. It stars Gregory Peck and Tuesday Weld and is based upon the book An Exile by Madison Jones. Adapted screenplay by Alvin Sargent. It doesn’t appear to have been a commercial or critical hit and everyone seemed to have forgotten about it, just as John Frankenheimer likely would have wanted. The Internet was silent on it for decades.
Until today.
While I was sitting on the porch and smokin and drinkin and blasting music at ungodly hours of the night, I pulled out iPhone 4 and clicked on the Tubi app. First thing I saw was I Walk the Line starring Gregory Peck and Tuesday Weld. I clicked on it and watched. 97 minutes later, the movie was over and I thought “that was a nice little movie” so I went on over to Facebook to post a halfassed review before I had to drag my drunk ass into work.
Here’s the review

Seems innocent enough, right? I thought critics overlooked this one is all. But come to find out people have opinions, particularly on Gregory Peck’s performance. Personally, I thought his acting fit the movie perfectly. The word I was trying to look for was alienated, as in I felt Peck’s character was alienated from his family, his job, his community. And the only thing that brought him out of his shell was meeting Tuesday Weld’s character. I read it as a midlife crisis movie and Peck delivered as an aging, bored, and depressed sheriff who perilously finds a new lease on life.
I guess I was wrong though.
Enter critic(?), movie writer, historian, and curator Paul Mavis. Other than me, he’s probably the only other man on this planet who has a midly passionate opinion about I Walk the Line.
For full transparency, our conversation (debate?) went as follows:









Ladies and gentlemen, what you just read is the equivalent of Plato Vs Aristotle. Noam Chomsky Vs Michel Foucault. Jordan B Peterson Vs Slavoj Zizek. The internet won’t soon forget.
First allow me to make a few concessions. Mr. Mavis’ view on the movie is valid, even if I disagree. If the quality of art was judged by popular vote, I’d be in the clear minority. I’d also be in the minority if I called The Matrix and Titanic dogshit, but I digress. He (presumably?) gets paid to evaluate film and he could very likely articulate why I Walk the Line is a bad movie better than I can argue that it’s a good movie. That’s not where my problem lies.
Where I do take issue is with his last point.
As my audience knows, I’m an artist. Not a good one, mind you. But an artist nonetheless. I’m a writer and have published a few books. What these strange and, frankly, stupid pieces of fiction mean to me is probably different than what they mean to you. I was told Stories You Should Never Read is satire. Yet my only real motivation behind writing them was that I wanted to tell dick and fart jokes. If you didn’t pick up on that, it’s fine. Once when I create something and it goes out to readers, how the reader perceives it is entirely out of my hands. The best I can do is be true to every word I put on paper. Thats true for all arts and artists. And there’s nothing we can do about it.
John Frankenheimer and Gregory Peck made a movie they weren’t proud of. It happens. Does that mean audiences aren’t allowed to like it? If John Frankenheimer was blind drunk—as he frequently was—and he called I Walk the Line the worst movie he ever made, and then I told him “actually you made a pretty good movie”, would he say I’m wrong and that I should actually hate it? I’m just a little confused as to why I should value his opinion above my own if that were the case. Plenty of artists have released shit work (in their view) that have become recognized as classic works of art.
It’s not delusion and hubris. And if it is, so be it. I’m sure Mr. Mavis has a soft spot some steaming pile of shit film that its own director despises. And he probably HATES a movie that everyone loves.
The ball is in your court Mr. Mavis.
